Charitable Giving: Beyond the Basics

Featured Post | Published at Dec 24, 2019, 12:00 AM in finance by Nick Maratta

We all love to give. It feels great to give to others, whether it is your favorite charity, or as a demonstration of love and support of friends and family members. However, just like any expense, giving should be budgeted, tracked, and done with intention. It is not healthy to give beyond one’s means. It is not wise to support financial dependence in others, or to give out of a sense of guilt or shame. Time spent in support of people and causes you love can be just as valuable, as a financial gesture. Many find this kind of hands on giving to be even more rewarding.

With the Holidays quickly approaching, we thought it would be fitting to cover the topic of charitable giving. The last few months of the year make up what is commonly called the Giving Season for the nonprofit community. As the holidays near, people often feel encouraged to give more generously than during the rest of the year.

Charitable giving can be a core value for many people. It may be a substantial priority in your life and in your financial plan. It feels good to give and to have an impact in our communities. Additionally, having a structure and plan around your charitable contributions can also have a positive financial impact for your family. Charitable donations can also bolster your tax deductions. This can help to reduce your overall tax liability. We support our clients’ charitable goals and values. We look to find efficient and optimal ways of incorporating those intentions into our planning process.

Let’s cover the basics. If you give money to a qualified organization, you may deduct the contribution from your adjusted gross income (generally up to 50%). For example, if you are in the 33% marginal tax bracket and make a donation of $1000, you will save $330 on taxes. There are many different strategies regarding charitable giving strategies. You have options besides just donating your personal items or giving cash. Here are some of the basics.

Appreciated Stock

You can give intangible personal property such as publicly traded stock (deductible up to 30% of your adjusted gross income, if more can be carried up to 5 years forward). Current long term capital gains tax on a stock when sold is either 15% or 20%. For example, let’s say your yearly goal is to give $20k a year to your church. You happen to own $20k worth of XYZ stock with a $10k long term capital gain built in. If you sell the stock and give the money to the church, you will pay $2k capital gains tax (profit of $10k times 20% if in the highest tax bracket). You will then get a $20k deduction. A better option would be to donate the $20k of stock to the church. With this action you eliminate the $2k of capital gains tax and still take the $20k deduction. The church would get the $20k worth of stock. They would most likely liquidate it immediately. This way they will still get the same benefit as if you gave twenty thousand dollars. If you still think that company is a good investment, you can turn around and buy more. You will then reset your cost basis to the current purchase price.

Donor Advised Fund

A Donor Advised Fund allows you to make an irrevocable charitable contribution to a fund. You will then get an immediate tax deduction. You can even donate capital appreciated stock into this type of fund. The funds can accumulate within the account and invested to grow. This ultimately gives a larger amount to your choice of Charity(s). You can then control the timing of the distribution of the fund to various charity organizations. This could be particularly useful in a year where you have a large amount of income.

In this case you are trying to offset a bountiful years income and have an ongoing charitable goal. For example, let’s say John just sold his business for millions of dollars which puts him in the highest tax bracket of 39.6%. Because this sale is a unique event he can expect to fall back into a 25% tax bracket next year. He can make a large lump sum contribution to a Donor Advised Fund. This will help him receive the immediate tax deduction the year he is in the highest tax bracket. He then can control the timing of distributions to his choice of charitable organization. There could be a variety of large income events where this strategy could be effective (Roth conversions, sudden wealth event, etc).

Required Minimum Distributions

The IRS has requirements for when taxpayers turn age 70 ½.. At this age they must start distributing their IRA’s and tax deferred accounts. This is called a RMD (required minimum distribution). You can opt to make a QCD (qualified charitable distribution) directly to your choice of a qualified charity. This will satisfy your RMD. You may be asking why you can’t just take the distribution and then make the donation. If you take a distribution, those funds are added to your AGI (adjusted gross income). If you turn around and then donate that same amount to charity, it does reduce your taxable income. Unfortunately it does not reduce your AGI. There is a benefit to donating directly. In this case the amount of distribution won’t ever be added to your AGI. Therefore you are avoiding triggers such as paying more in Medicare or taxability of your social security. You can also avoid itemized deduction phase outs and net investment income tax. You can still get the deduction even if you don’t itemize your tax deductions (charitable donations don’t help if taking standard deduction).

These are just a couple basic strategies that can optimize your charitable giving. As you can see, there are ways around developing a more effective giving strategy than just writing a check. With any strategy, there are nuances you may want to be aware of and would be best to consult a competent advisor.

Happy Holidays!

Nick Maratta, MBA, CFP®

Managing Partner